The GAAR Advisory Panel found transactions with a pension scheme that purported to create a transaction akin to a loan, but without an unauthorised payment charge arising, were not a reasonable course of action.

The General Anti-Abuse Rule (GAAR) Advisory Panel was asked to consider arrangements whereby:

  • A pension scheme was established on 20 January 2016 for a single member (M).
  • The trustees of the scheme were M and a professional trustee company (Trustees).
  • On May 2016 the value of the scheme stood at £263k which was largely made up of a transfer from another scheme.
  • In June 2016 the Trustees agreed to purchase a low-risk investment (Investment) for £100k.
  • In July 2016 the Trustees agreed with M that:
    • M will buy the Investment for £100k.
    • M will pay the purchase price in 10 annual instalments which were to include interest.
    • The Investment was sold to M.
    • M surrendered the investment and £100k in cash.

The GAAR Advisory Panel opined that the arrangements were not a reasonable course of action in relation to the tax provisions as:

  • The arrangements were tax arrangements as:
    • The pre-planned steps resulted in M receiving tax-free cash as a result of transactions undertaken by and with the pension scheme.
  • The entering into the arrangements was abnormal and contrived as:
    • The terms of payment provided to M were in contrast to industry norms which required an immediate cash payment.
    • The surrender of the investment by M shortly after acquisition, suggested the reason for the arrangements was to cause an outflow of cash from the pension scheme to M.
  • The arrangements were abusive as:

The panel found that entering into and carrying out the arrangements were not a reasonable course of action in relation to the relevant tax provisions.

Useful guides on this topic

Pensions: Unauthorised payment charge
What is a pensions unauthorised payment? When does a tax charge arise? Who pays the charge? 

General Anti-Abuse Rule (GAAR) (subscriber version)
What is the General Anti-Abuse Rule (GAAR)? When does it apply? 

External links

GAAR Advisory Panel opinion of 15 September 2022: Unauthorised payment from registered pension scheme involving debt arrangement