The government has published a response to its consultation ‘Proposals to tackle lower value tax debts’. It confirms that HMRC will introduce a new power to recover tax debts through regular deductions from the bank accounts of taxpayers who persistently fail to engage with HMRC.

Tax debt loan

HMRC have reported that each year around 750,000 lower-value tax debts, worth £2 billion, remain unpaid despite attempts by debt collection agencies to recover them. Some of the tax collection tools available to HMRC are resource-intensive and therefore not always proportionate to lower-value debts.

A Consultation that ran until 28 August 2026 proposed a new power to deduct affordable monthly instalments from the bank accounts of taxpayers who persistently fail to engage with HMRC through automated processes.

  • The power would apply only after standard collection activity has been exhausted.
  • The power would be supported by affordability assessments, manual review for customers requiring extra support, advance notice and rights to object, as well as an appeals and redress process.

The proposals would run alongside the existing Direct Recovery of Debts system, which allows collection of one-time lump sums from tax defaulters.

Responses

The consultation received 65 responses.

  • Respondents broadly supported recovering established tax debts from taxpayers who persistently fail to engage.
  • They also supported the use of the power only as a last resort, after standard collection activity has been exhausted.
    • HMRC say a taxpayer will typically have been contacted at least 10 times, and the debt will be at least nine months old, before deductions begin.
  • Many respondents agreed that taxpayers should be issued with a pre-deduction notice before starting deductions. Though many felt that the proposed 14-day notice period might not give taxpayers enough time to seek advice and gather evidence.
  • Some respondents raised concerns that proposals to take debts from joint accounts might result in funds being taken from a non-debtor.
  • Respondents welcomed the proposal to remove customers requiring extra support from automation, instead providing a manual review.
    • They felt the greater challenge is identifying vulnerable taxpayers, which is difficult where there has been no engagement.
  • Respondents cautioned that no automated method can reliably establish disposable incomes for the purposes of assessing affordability of repayments. Some suggested introducing a minimum protected bank account balance.
  • Respondents supported a formal objection process but called for effective redress where HMRC make an error.  

Next steps

The government will proceed with developing the proposed policy.

  • The policy will apply to individuals and companies, covering all debts administered by HMRC, including associated interest and penalties.
  • This would apply to total debts of up to £5,000 for individuals and £10,000 for companies.
    • These limits will be reviewed after implementation.
  • A formal pre-deduction notice would be issued informing the taxpayer of the debt being recovered. The minimum notice period before deductions begin will be 28 days.
  • Each taxpayer will receive a tailored affordability assessment, though the methodology is not yet finalised.
  • A trained HMRC officer will manually review any case where vulnerability or a need for extra support is identified.
  • Any taxpayer who engages with HMRC to manage their debt will be removed from the process.
  • Tax Credit debts will be excluded, but Child Benefit debt will not. Managed or disputed debts, and customers who are deceased or subject to insolvency proceedings, will also remain outside the scope.
  • The policy will initially apply to current accounts only.
    • Collection will be available from joint accounts, but only where no suitable sole account is available. Where HMRC hold the necessary information, they will notify the non-debtor before any deduction and allow them to object.
    • HMRC will not be able to recover debts from authorised overdrafts for individuals, though they will for companies.
  • Under a 'refund first' safeguard, a taxpayer who objects to a deduction would receive a refund of the disputed amount while HMRC review the case. Deductions will be paused while HMRC review an obligation.

The next steps are:

  • The government will co-design a Code of Practice with stakeholders and publish a first draft in Summer 2027.
  • Following this, draft legislation will be published for technical consultation in Summer 2027, with a view to inclusion in the next available Finance Bill.
  • A test and learn phase is planned from 2028 to Spring 2029 on a limited scale.
  • A phased rollout will begin from the 2029-30 financial year, starting with companies before extending to individuals.

Useful guides on this topic

Direct Recovery of Debts (enforcement by deduction from accounts)
When can HMRC recover debts directly from persistent non-payers? What safeguards are in place for taxpayers?

How to appeal a tax penalty (subscriber version)
What are the steps in making an appeal? What should an appeal cover? What does recent case law say on this topic?

Time to Pay agreement
Businesses and self-employed taxpayers with outstanding tax liabilities may be eligible for support with their tax affairs through HMRC’s Time To Pay service.

External links

Consultation outcome: Tackling lower value tax debts

Factsheet: Tackling lower value tax debts factsheet