The government has published its response to the consultation 'Requiring payment of VAT and PAYE return liabilities by Direct Debit'. Following strong opposition to mandatory Direct Debit, businesses will still be able to pay by their preferred method. However, from April 2029, any return liability still unpaid at the due date will be collected by Direct Debit.

Most taxpayers pay VAT and PAYE in full and on time. A minority pay late, often because of oversight or because a payment has been made incorrectly, rather than because they cannot or will not pay.
- Common problems include wrong amounts, incorrect payment references and simply forgetting to pay. These errors generate a significant flow of debt for HMRC and can leave businesses facing interest and penalties.
Direct Debit automates payment once a return has been submitted.
- The business no longer has to track deadlines, make a separate payment or manually enter a payment reference.
- At the moment, around 330,000 businesses already use Direct Debit for VAT and PAYE, out of a population of about 2.7 million.
The intention to consult was announced at Autumn Budget 2025. The Consultation was launched in June 2026 and closed on 18 August. It sought views on requiring businesses to pay VAT and PAYE return liabilities by Direct Debit, including the benefits, practical barriers, business impacts, exceptions, incentives and sanctions.
Responses
HMRC received 413 responses. Most respondents were small businesses, and most did not use, and have never used, Direct Debit to pay HMRC.
- Respondents broadly agreed with the aim of improving payment timeliness. Many recognised the benefits of Direct Debit, including less administration and a lower risk of missed deadlines. Just over 43% cited automation or reduced administration as potential benefits.
- Even so, 80.2% of respondents opposed mandating Direct Debit. Only 4.3% supported it, 14.5% were neutral, and 1% expressed different or qualified views.
- Cash flow and control were the dominant concerns. Businesses wanted to decide when money leaves their account, and to pay early if they choose. Some warned that automatic collection could cause overdrafts, bank charges or failed payments. One insolvency practitioner noted that directors in financial distress need to manage competing liabilities, and that automatic collection could accelerate insolvency.
- Concerns about how Direct Debit would work in practice included collection dates around weekends and holidays, and whether late changes to a liability (such as VAT error corrections or PAYE amendments) would be reflected in the amount collected. Some also asked how it would interact with Time to Pay arrangements.
- Agents said they have limited visibility of clients' Direct Debit arrangements. They wanted to be able to set up mandates, check whether they were active and see the amount to be collected before payment is taken.
- Trust in HMRC's systems was a recurring theme. Accountants and representative bodies reported payments being misallocated, for example, across payroll periods or even tax years, and slow resolution of errors. They feared these problems would be magnified if the amount shown as due led directly to an automated collection.
- Respondents argued that some groups would need exemptions. These include the digitally excluded, businesses with overseas bank accounts, those with strict dual-authorisation or governance control, and charities and regulated financial services firms with restricted accounts. Large businesses also face a banking system limit of £20 million on Direct Debit payments.
- On sanctions and incentives, respondents overwhelmingly opposed penalties based solely on payment method, noting that interest and penalties already apply to late payment. Most preferred incentives, such as later payment deadlines or the option of monthly instalments, although views were mixed on having different deadlines for different payment methods.
Next steps
The government has said it listened to the clear feedback from businesses, while recognising the need to manage debt and the cost of payment errors. Rather than requiring all businesses to pay by Direct Debit, it will adopt the following approach:
- Businesses can continue to pay VAT and PAYE return liabilities using their current payment methods.
- From April 2029, Direct Debit will operate as a safeguard. Any return liability that remains unpaid at the due date will be collected automatically.
- Businesses will be required to set up a Direct Debit instruction for VAT and PAYE return payments unless they are exempt.
- The requirement will be reviewed if Direct Debit is superseded by another automated payment method before April 2029.
The government acknowledged concerns about HMRC's IT systems, the misallocation of payments and agents' access to client accounts. It says HMRC will use the lead-in time to work on IT improvements and review agent services.
HMRC will continue to work with businesses and agents to finalise the policy. This includes the exemptions that will be needed, how to encourage early take-up of automated payments and the consequences of continued non-compliance. Communications and guidance will be published ahead of April 2029.
Useful guides on this topic
Calendar of tax deadlines and new tax measures
When do common recurring tax deadlines fall? What other tax-significant events are upcoming? What do I need to remember this month?
Deadlines: compliance (individuals & companies)
Every UK taxpayer has filing obligations and deadlines. There are penalties for late and inaccurate submissions. What are the deadlines? What penalties can be charged for missing the deadlines?
Penalties (VAT)
When do penalties apply for VAT? What penalties are charged and how can they be mitigated?
Penalties: PAYE and late payment
What tax penalties apply for late-paid PAYE and NIC? What should an employer consider when handling late payment issues under PAYE? How are penalties calculated and how can you appeal?
External link
Requiring payment of VAT and PAYE return liabilities by Direct Debit - Summary of responses